2009 ALL SCR 1619
TARUN CHATTERJEE AND R.M. LODHA, JJ.
Rampal Vs. State Of Haryana & Ors.
Civil Appeal No.5076 of 2009,(SLP) No.13023 of 2008
4th August, 2009
Constitution of India, Art.341 - Caste-claim - Appellant alleged to have produced caste certificate showing him as belonging to "Sirkiband" caste while in fact he belonged to "Banjara" caste - Certificate cancelled by Tahsildar without giving him opportunity of hearing - Order of cancellation set aside. (Para 6)
3. The appellant, at the relevant point of time, was working as a Constable but he got entry in service by producing a caste certificate showing him as a scheduled caste candidate. It appears that one complaint was made against him that he got the said certificate wrongly, by showing himself as belonging to 'Sirkiband' caste whereas in fact he belongs to 'Banjara' caste, which cannot be said to be a "Scheduled Caste". On enquiry by the Tahsildar, this certificate of the appellant was cancelled. It was the grievance of the appellant that before cancelling the certificate, no opportunity of hearing was granted to him and accordingly, the order of cancellation must be set aside.
6. We have heard the learned counsel for the parties and examined the impugned order and other materials on record. In our view, the appeal is liable to be allowed and the impugned order should also be set aside on a very short point. It is an admitted position that before cancellation of the caste certificate of the appellant, the authorities ought to have given an opportunity of hearing to the appellant and also to contend that the Certificate issued to him was a "Scheduled Caste Certificate" and, therefore, it cannot be quashed. In view of the fact that the principles of natural justice was admittedly violated in this case, the impugned order must be set aside and the concerned Tahsildar must be directed to decide the dispute regarding the caste certificate of the appellant after giving hearing to the parties and after passing a reasoned order, preferably within three months from the date of supply of a copy of this order to him.